Amy Coney Barret was sworn into the senate as the 115th Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court on October 27, 2020. After the passing of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the President’s top pick to fill the vacancy was Amy Barret. She was confirmed shortly after, and this sparked a lot of controversial conversation. As a federal judge, she had compiled almost an entirely conservative voting record on cases regarding abortion, gun control and rights, discrimination, immigration and more. One of the biggest risks of her obtaining this position is her power to shift the rest of the court and compromise Roe v. Wade (right to an abortion).
Her political views and actions mirror those of Antonin Scalia whom she worked for in the past, as a law clerk. President Trump’s goal was to appoint justices who are ready to overrule Roe v. Wade and Amy Coney Barrett’s views align with that goal. Amy Barret is from Indiana and while there, she had considered three different cases on abortion and expressed her disagreements on the court rulings on them. While the court had ruled in favor of the right to these abortion cases, she was on the losing side and continued to vote against abortions on future cases.
I think this confirmation can possibly be detrimental to women’s rights in the future; not only regarding Roe v. Wade, but also other court rulings that give women the rights and freedoms that we currently have. Amy Coney Barret will be a very influential member of the Supreme Court and will most likely vote for the suppression of these rights. Despite her being a woman, she clearly doesn’t believe that all women deserve the rights and choices to decide what’s best for themselves and their health. Her confirmation may not really affect me right now, but it will certainly have an effect on other women and could affect my rights in the future. I am very disappointed in this nomination as I feel like she is not the best pick to fill RBG’s seat, she doesn’t even come close, in my opinion; I don’t believe that she has the best intentions for ALL Americans based on her political history. It is still early stages regarding this confirmation, and despite her political views and past voting records, I am still hopeful that she will not shift the court too much to the right which could potentially affect the lives of millions.
Sources:
https://filmdaily.co/news/amy-coney-barrett-scotus/
https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/senate-confirms-amy-coney-barrett-supreme-court/
